Active Noise Cancelling vs Noise Isolating Headphones: Which Should You Buy?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing active noise cancelling vs noise isolating headphones to decide which technology fits your daily routine. Both the Beats Studio Pro and the Skullcandy Crusher Evo are wireless over-ear models with identical battery life. The main difference lies in how they handle external sound. One uses electronic processing to block noise, while the other relies on physical sealing to dampen it. Understanding these distinct approaches helps you choose the right tool for your environment.
Key differences
| Aspect | Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones | Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones |
|---|---|---|
| Noise Cancellation Type | Active Noise Cancelling (ANC) | Noise Isolating |
| Audio Features | Spatial Audio, Lossless audio | Multi-Sensory Bass |
| Connectivity | Class 1 Bluetooth, USB-C, 3.5 mm | Bluetooth |
| Weight | 9.17 ounces | 1.78 ounces |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones if
- You need to block out consistent background noise in flights or offices using ANC.
- You want to use lossless audio via USB-C or connect via a 3.5 mm cable.
- You prefer spatial audio with dynamic head tracking for movies and music.
Choose Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones if
- You want to physically feel bass vibrations through multi-sensory drivers.
- You prioritize a lighter, more portable design for easy travel.
- You prefer passive isolation that requires no power for noise reduction.
Verdict: The Beats Studio Pro suits you if you need active noise cancellation and high-fidelity audio features like lossless support. The Skullcandy Crusher Evo is better if you want a lighter build and a unique bass experience you can feel. Choose based on whether you prefer electronic noise blocking or physical sound immersion.
ANC vs Isolation Headphones Compared
Noise Cancellation Type
The Beats Studio Pro uses active noise cancelling technology to block distractions in noisy environments like flights or commutes. It also offers a Transparency mode to let external sounds mix in with your music. The Skullcandy Crusher Evo relies on noise isolating over-ear fit. This physical seal blocks sound passively rather than using electronic signals to cancel noise. If you need to actively suppress engine roar or office chatter, the Beats approach is more effective. If you prefer a passive seal without electronic processing, the Skullcandy design suits you.
Audio Features
Beats Studio Pro supports lossless audio via USB-C and includes spatial audio with personalized dynamic head tracking. This creates a 360-degree immersive experience for movies and music. Skullcandy Crusher Evo features patented multi-sensory bass technology. It uses two full-range 40mm drivers plus dual bass drivers to produce sound you can physically feel. Beats focuses on clarity and spatial immersion, while Skullcandy emphasizes tactile low-frequency impact. Your choice depends on whether you want precise, wide soundstages or physical bass sensation.
Connectivity
Beats Studio Pro offers versatile connectivity options including Class 1 Bluetooth, USB-C for lossless audio, and a 3.5 mm cable for analog listening. It supports one-touch pairing with both Apple and Android devices. Skullcandy Crusher Evo connects via Bluetooth. The data does not specify if it supports lossless audio or includes a 3.5 mm cable. Beats provides more flexible connection methods for different devices and audio quality needs. Skullcandy offers standard wireless connectivity but lacks the specified wired lossless option in the provided data.
Microphone
Beats Studio Pro includes voice-targeting microphones designed to reduce background noise during calls. This ensures crisp and clear call performance in offices or while moving. The data for Skullcandy Crusher Evo mentions button controls for answering or rejecting calls but does not specify microphone technology or noise reduction features for voice. Beats is better suited for clear voice communication in noisy environments due to its dedicated noise-reducing mic array. Skullcandy provides basic call functionality without specified acoustic processing for your voice.
Form Factor
Both headphones are over-ear models designed for all-day comfort. Beats Studio Pro features UltraPlush comfort cushions and weighs 9.17 ounces. Skullcandy Crusher Evo has a noise isolating over-ear fit and weighs 1.78 ounces. The Skullcandy model is significantly lighter. Both designs aim for extended listening sessions. Beats prioritizes plush cushioning for comfort, while Skullcandy offers a lighter build. If weight is a primary concern, the Skullcandy option is noticeably lighter. If plush cushioning is preferred, the Beats design provides that specific comfort feature.
Which headphones fit your needs?
Travelers needing silence on flights
The Beats Studio Pro uses active noise cancelling to block distractions during commutes or flights. Its Transparency mode lets environmental sounds mix with your music when needed. This feature set prioritizes acoustic control over physical seal, making it ideal for noisy transit where electronic cancellation is more effective than passive isolation.
Listeners wanting tactile bass feel
The Skullcandy Crusher Evo features patented multi-sensory bass technology with dual bass drivers. You can feel the sound physically, which enhances movies and music. This model relies on noise isolating over-ear fit rather than electronic cancellation, offering a unique sensory experience that active noise cancelling headphones cannot replicate through their standard driver arrays.
Users needing lossless audio quality
The Beats Studio Pro supports lossless audio via USB-C, optimizing music quality across devices. It also offers spatial audio with dynamic head tracking for immersive listening. These audio features provide a higher fidelity experience compared to the Crusher Evo, which focuses on bass impact rather than detailed lossless transmission or spatial positioning.
Quick picks
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones | Travelers needing long battery and ANC | Check price of Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones on Amazon |
| 2 | Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones | Tactile bass lovers | Check price of Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones on Amazon |
The products compared
Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones
Best for: Travelers needing long battery and ANC
- Noise Cancellation Type
- Active Noise Cancelling (what this guide is about)
- Noise Cancellation
- ANC, Transparency mode
- Form Factor
- Over-ear
- Battery Life
- Up to 40 hours
- Connectivity
- Class 1 Bluetooth, USB-C, 3.5 mm
- Audio Features
- Spatial Audio, Lossless audio
View on Amazon: Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones Affiliate link
The Beats Studio Pro is an over-ear headphone with active noise cancellation and transparency mode. It offers up to 40 hours of battery life and supports lossless audio via USB-C. You get spatial audio with head tracking and Class 1 Bluetooth for stable wireless connections. The design includes UltraPlush cushions for comfort. This model suits travelers and commuters who need distraction-free listening and long battery endurance.
Pros
- Active noise cancellation blocks external distractions
- Transparency mode allows environmental sound in
- Up to 40-hour battery life with fast charging
- USB-C lossless audio support for high quality
- Spatial audio with personalized dynamic head tracking
Cons
- Heavier at 9.17 ounces compared to lighter competitors
- Lacks dedicated companion app for EQ customization
- No physical remote for media control on the cable
Good fit if
- You need active noise cancellation for travel
- You want lossless audio via USB-C
- You prefer over-ear comfort for long sessions
Skip if
- You require a lightweight design under 8 ounces
- You need a dedicated app for sound tuning
- You prefer noise isolating passive headphones only
Verdict: Beats Studio Pro Over-Ear ANC delivers strong active noise cancellation and 40-hour battery life for travelers. It fits users who value lossless audio and spatial immersion over lightweight portability.
Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones
Best for: Tactile bass lovers
- Noise Cancellation Type
- Noise Isolating (what this guide is about)
- Noise Cancellation
- Noise isolating
- Form Factor
- Over-ear
- Battery Life
- Up to 40 hours
- Connectivity
- Bluetooth
- Driver Size
- 40 mm
View on Amazon: Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones Affiliate link
The Skullcandy Crusher Evo uses noise isolating over-ear fit to block ambient sound without active cancellation. It features patented multi-sensory bass with dual bass drivers for tactile feedback. You get up to 40 hours of battery life and rapid charge support. The app allows personal sound adjustment via hearing analysis. This model suits listeners who prefer physical bass sensation over electronic noise reduction.
Pros
- Patented multi-sensory bass with dual bass drivers
- Up to 40 hours battery life with rapid charge
- Personal Sound app for hearing analysis
- Flat-folding and collapsible design for portability
Cons
- Noise isolating only, lacks active noise cancellation
- No active noise cancellation for noisy environments
- Heavier build than typical isolating headphones
Good fit if
- You want tactile bass feedback
- You prefer noise isolating fit
- You need long battery life
Skip if
- You need active noise cancellation
- You want silent isolation
- You prefer lightweight design
Verdict: Skullcandy Crusher Evo Over-Ear fits bass lovers who want physical vibration. It lacks active noise cancellation for travel.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Beats Studio Pro Wireless Over-Ear Headphones | Skullcandy Crusher Evo Wireless Over-Ear Headphones |
|---|---|---|
| Noise Cancellation | ANC, Transparency mode | Noise isolating |
| Form Factor | Over-ear | Over-ear |
| Battery Life | Up to 40 hours | Up to 40 hours |
| Connectivity | Class 1 Bluetooth, USB-C, 3.5 mm | Bluetooth |
| Driver Size | not stated | 40 mm |
| Audio Features | Spatial Audio, Lossless audio | not stated |
| Noise Cancellation Type | Active Noise Cancelling | Noise Isolating |
| Recommended Use | Travel | not stated |
| Color | Black | Blue/Grey |
| Dimensions | 7.01 × 3.07 × 7.13 inches | 8.47 × 9.13 × 2.72 inches |
| Weight | 9.17 ounces | 1.78 ounces |
| Size | One Size | One Size |
| Model | MQTP3DN/A | S6EVW-S979 |
Frequently asked questions
Does active noise cancelling block all sound?
No, active noise cancelling reduces low-frequency droning sounds like airplane engines or train rumble. It uses microphones and speakers to generate inverse sound waves. High-pitched noises like voices or sudden claps often remain audible. You should expect significant reduction, not total silence, in your audio environment.
How do noise isolating headphones work?
Noise isolating headphones rely on physical barriers to block sound. They use tight seals around the ear or in-ear tips to prevent external noise from entering. This method does not require power or electronics. You get passive reduction based on the fit and materials of the ear cups or tips.
Can I use active noise cancelling headphones without power?
Yes, you can use them as standard passive headphones when the battery dies. The ear cups still provide some isolation through their physical design. However, you lose the active cancellation feature. You might notice more ambient noise compared to when the battery is fully charged.
Which is better for travel, ANC or isolation?
Active noise cancelling is generally better for travel. It effectively dampens continuous low-frequency sounds from engines and air conditioning. The Beats Studio Pro offers 40 hours of battery life, making it suitable for long trips. Noise isolating headphones may struggle with constant background rumble without active processing.
Do noise isolating headphones need batteries?
No, noise isolating headphones do not require batteries. They function purely through physical design and materials. This means you can use them indefinitely without charging. The Skullcandy Crusher Evo uses isolation, so you do not need to worry about power levels affecting noise blocking performance.
Are active noise cancelling headphones heavier?
They often are slightly heavier due to internal electronics. The Beats Studio Pro weighs 9.17 ounces and includes components for active cancellation. Noise isolating models may be lighter if they lack these extra parts. However, the Skullcandy Crusher Evo weighs only 1.78 ounces, showing weight varies by design.
Is transparency mode part of noise isolation?
No, transparency mode is a feature of active noise cancelling systems. It uses microphones to let external sounds in. The Skullcandy Crusher Evo relies on isolation and lacks this digital feature. You must physically remove the headphones to hear your surroundings clearly if you only have isolating models.